This is the LAST of 20 posts I will be writing during the PARCC testing window of March 9 – April 10. If you’re interested in the growing master list of reasons we opted out of standardized tests in 2015, you can find it here.
Reason 20: Because We Can
In many ways we are the perfect and not-so-perfect parents to serve as a public symbol of the opt-out movement.
We are perfect because we know exactly why we are opting out and can explain it in 6000+ word manifestos that criticize the standardized testing racket with research-backed and experience-based critiques. This is due largely to my experience as a middle school teacher in a public school, the Ph.D. I hold in Curriculum and Instruction, and the connections I have with teachers from around the country. If there’s a story out there, I’ve probably heard it and I can relate it to research while throwing in a personal anecdote from my own experiences to make a point. As a university professor part of my responsibility is to engage in public outreach, so I view my blogging as part of my job, though the “credit” I receive for it doesn’t quite match the effort I put in. I am also currently aware of the legal precedents surrounding parents’ rights when it comes to educating their child though I’m hardly a legal expert.
On the other hand we are also not-so-perfect role models because our situation doesn’t really reflect the reality that most parents face when trying to decide whether or not to opt their children out of standardized tests. I haven’t faced the same threats that other parents have faced when informing their child’s school of their intentions to opt out. Whether that is because they don’t want to mess with a guy who can make a very public mess out of the situation or because our school district is particularly enlightened isn’t totally clear to me. Then there’s the fact that I just keep our children home with me when they are opting out. My job allows me the flexibility to work from lots of places (currently writing this at Panera) and home is one of them. This makes it much easier to opt out because we don’t have to worry about sending our kids to school and putting the responsibility for opting out on them. I’m constantly impressed by the stories I see of students who refuse the tests, often enduring the “sit and stare” treatment (i.e. they are required to sit and have nothing to do but stare at the wall during the test they are refusing). Our children don’t have to face that.
All in all, opting out is relatively easy for us. We are privileged in that regard and it is important for us to recognize that privilege. But we also believe that it is important for us to use that privilege to do what is right. It would be arguably more beneficial for us to have our children take the PARCC. They would undoubtedly score well, which is reflective of their ability and the relatively privileged situation they live in. They would almost certainly be among the “desired” students courted by schools of choice because their ability and socioeconomic status fit the profile. That said, we sacrifice relatively little compared to other parents who wish to opt their children out of standardized tests but have a more difficult time asserting their parental rights.
Every parent should have the right to make the choice that has been relatively easy for us to make. I’ve consulted with lots of parents and most choose not to opt their kids out of standardized tests though it’s usually because they are afraid of the consequences, not because they believe tests are good for their children. I suppose that’s one of the aspects of standardized testing in the U.S. that concerns me the most. There are few things that schools can impose upon parents and those that are imposed are designed for safety or protecting the learning environment. Take immunizations for instance. Schools require them because there’s a mountain of research that says they protect children, despite what former Playboy cover models will argue. Still, you can opt your kids out of immunizations if you really want to with a religious exemption. Yet, when it comes to standardized tests, states are adamant that there is NO exception for opting out. This is concerning because unlike immunizations, the mountain of evidence about standardized testing doesn’t point to them being all that great for children.
When parents are compelled to subject their children to tests with a fervor unlike anything else in our schools, then one certainly has to wonder why. Of course, if you’ve read the 20 days of opt-out posts I’ve laid out over the past month then I’m sure you’re not wondering at all.